Question 1

What's a typical contingency fee structure?

Accepted Answer

ABA Model Rule 1.5 governs contingency fee reasonableness but doesn't set specific percentages. Market practice in personal injury: 33⅓% (one-third) for cases resolved pre-litigation (settlement before filing a lawsuit); 40% for cases that require filing a lawsuit (post-filing, pre-appeal); 45% for cases that go through appeal. Some firms use 25% pre-suit / 33⅓% post-filing / 40% post-trial. Class actions and mass torts use court-supervised fee structures, often 25–33% subject to lodestar cross-check. Statutory fee-shifting cases (civil rights, employment, consumer protection) use 'reasonable attorney's fees' determined by the court, often with a lodestar method (hours × hourly rate × multiplier).

Question 2

Which states cap contingency fees?

Accepted Answer

Several states cap contingency fees, especially in medical malpractice. Florida: Rule Regulating Florida Bar 4-1.5(f)(4)(B) caps med-mal at 30% of the first $250K + 10% of amounts above. California: Cal. Bus. & Prof. Code §6146 caps med-mal at 40% of first $50K, 33⅓% of next $50K, 25% of next $500K, 15% of amount above $600K. Connecticut, Massachusetts, New Jersey, New York, Tennessee, and several others have similar med-mal caps. For non-med-mal personal injury, most states do not cap percentages but require court approval for fees exceeding 'reasonable' under ABA Rule 1.5. Always check your state bar's current rules — these caps are periodically reviewed.

Question 3

What case costs come out of the settlement?

Accepted Answer

'Case costs' (sometimes called 'litigation costs' or 'expenses') are separate from attorney fees and are typically reimbursed off the top before the contingency fee is calculated — OR after, depending on the retainer agreement. Common case costs in a personal injury matter: filing fees (~$200–500), service of process ($75–150), deposition court reporter + transcript fees ($1,000–5,000 per deposition × 5–20 depositions on a serious case), expert witness fees (medical experts $3,000–10,000 per deposition + $5,000–25,000 for trial testimony; vocational rehabilitation experts; economists; accident reconstructionists), exhibit preparation, trial graphics, focus groups, mock trials. Total case costs on a serious injury case can range from $5,000 (quick pre-suit settlement) to $100,000+ (trial-prepared case with expert testimony). Read the retainer agreement carefully to determine whether costs come off the top or off the bottom.

Question 4

What are 'liens' on a personal injury settlement?

Accepted Answer

Liens are claims that third parties have against the settlement proceeds for medical bills they paid or services they provided. Common liens in personal injury: (1) Medicare conditional payments — federal lien under 42 USC §1395y(b); must be repaid before settlement disbursement, with a multi-step Medicare-set-aside (MSA) process for future medical care; (2) Medicaid recovery — state-by-state but federal Medicaid law (42 USC §1396p) provides recovery rights; (3) ERISA self-funded health plans — federally preempted; can demand full reimbursement under US Airways v. McCutchen and similar cases; (4) hospital liens — state statutory; varies; some states cap at 30% of settlement; (5) workers' compensation offset — if the injury is also a workplace injury, the employer/carrier has subrogation rights; (6) Veterans Administration — separate federal lien for VA medical care. Lien negotiation can recover 10–50% of the lien amount; this is a critical attorney-managed step often overlooked by clients reviewing settlement math.

Question 5

How is the settlement taxed?

Accepted Answer

Per IRC §104(a)(2), compensation for personal physical injuries or physical sickness is excluded from gross income — tax-free at federal level, and most states follow. This includes lost wages, pain and suffering, emotional distress related to physical injury, and medical expense reimbursement. Exceptions that ARE taxable: (a) punitive damages — always taxable per Schleier v. US (1995); (b) interest accrued on the settlement (post-judgment, pre-payment); (c) emotional distress claims without physical injury — taxable; (d) employment discrimination claims (Title VII, ADEA) — taxable; (e) breach of contract damages — taxable. Allocation matters: a $1M settlement allocated $700K to physical injury + $300K to punitive damages results in $300K of taxable income. Settlement agreement language is critical — generic 'general damages' language may not survive IRS scrutiny. CPA/tax-attorney review of settlement-agreement allocation before signing is recommended on settlements above $100K.

Question 6

What's the typical take-home percentage on a personal injury settlement?

Accepted Answer

Highly variable, but a common reference: from a $100K gross settlement, plaintiff typically takes home $30–55K after attorney fees (33–40%), case costs ($2–10K), and liens ($10–25K depending on whether Medicare/Medicaid/ERISA are involved). Take-home on serious injury cases with significant medical care can be lower (heavy lien load) or higher (large settlement with same fixed costs). Take-home ratio improves with settlement size because case costs and lien negotiation efficiency don't scale proportionally — a $1M settlement might net $550–650K, a 55–65% take-home rate, while a $50K settlement might net $20–25K, a 40–50% take-home rate. This calculator surfaces the breakdown so the take-home is transparent before settlement is accepted.

Question 7

Can I negotiate the contingency fee?

Accepted Answer

Yes — contingency fees are negotiable. The market rate is the default, not the cap. Cases with strong liability and clear damages (e.g., rear-end collision with documented injuries against a corporate defendant) often command lower contingencies (25–30%) because they're easier to settle. Cases with disputed liability, weak damages, or sympathetic-defendant facts often command standard or higher contingencies (35–40%) because they require more attorney time and risk. Sliding-scale fees (lower percentage on easier-resolved portion + higher on harder-fought portion) are common. Get fee terms in writing in a signed retainer agreement before the attorney begins work — ABA Model Rule 1.5(c) requires written contingency fee agreements.

Question 8

What about attorney's fees on uncollected portions?

Accepted Answer

A common dispute: settlement is reached, but the defendant is judgment-proof or the insurance policy limits don't cover full recovery. If the contingency is 33⅓% of $500K settlement but defendant can only pay $200K, does the attorney get $66K (one-third of the actual collection) or $166K (one-third of the nominal settlement)? Most retainer agreements specify the fee is on 'amounts actually collected,' not 'settlement amount.' This matters most in cases with structured settlements (paid over years), bankrupt defendants, or insurance disputes. Read the retainer carefully.

Contingency Fee Calculator

Inputs coming in next batch

Frequently asked questions